Problem Set #9 Problem 1 -- Clarification

Problem Set #9 Problem 1 -- Clarification

by Michael Kohn -
Number of replies: 0

Parts a-g of Problem 1 ask you to assume that whether a premature baby is screened for PDA by ultrasound is NOT independently related to in-hospital mortality.  This makes screening a good instrumental variable which is associated with PDA treatment and not otherwise associated with mortality.

Parts h and i, ask you to drop that assumption.  The assumption behind parts h and i is that certain characteristics of the baby make both screening and death more likely. In other words, confounding affects the association between screening and death.  In parts h and i, the intervention of interest is screening itself, not PDA treatment, and the problem of confounding is addressed by comparing screened and unscreened infants matched on propensity score.

I tried to clarify this in the newly posted version of the problem set.