Assignment 1

Assignment 1

by Ekland Abdiwahab -
Number of replies: 3

African American women have higher rates of breast cancer mortality than any other racial/ethnic group. These disparities persist even after accounting for tumor stage and characteristics. Efforts to reduce disparities have largely focused on breast cancer screening. These efforts have been successful as screening rates between Black and White women have converged over the last decade. Currently breast cancer disparities are found mainly in timely diagnosis and treatment. There is evidence that obtaining cancer treatment at a National Cancer Institute designated-Comprehensive Cancer Center (NCICCC) results in significantly lower mortality than receiving treatment at non-NCICCC. In a population-based study of 69,579 patients (22-65 years of age) newly diagnosed with cancer, Wolfson et al found that women who were diagnosed with breast cancer and who received treatment at a non-NCICCC facility had higher 5-year mortality than women who received treatment at a NCICCC [HR: 1.3 (95%: 1.1-1.7)]. In addition, they found that patients who were underrepresented minority (African American or Hispanic), those who were older (40-65), those who were low SES, those who were uninsured, and those that lived more than 9 miles from the nearest NCICCC were less likely to be treated at a NCICCC. Factors that influence higher survival at NCICCCs include better surgical outcomes, organizational affiliation, and guideline compliance. I'm interested in understanding ways to get African American women, who tend to be lower income, into NCICCCs.  The biggest hurdle here is economics; how do we change the types of insurance NCICCCs accept. I assume there must be ways to incentivize health systems.

Wolfson, J. A., Sun, C. L., Wyatt, L. P., Hurria, A., & Bhatia, S. (2015). Impact of care at comprehensive cancer centers on outcome: Results from a population‐based study. Cancer121(21), 3885-3893.


In reply to Ekland Abdiwahab

Re: Assignment 1

by Timothy -

Hi Ekland,

You note an important disparity in health outcomes - the data your provide makes me wonder, will the most effective intervention be improving access to NCI centers or improving the care delivered at non-NCI centers? Is there data around why the disparity between centers exists? I imaging having all patients seek care at NCI centers would be difficult as breast cancer is a relatively common disease and I think there are only around 60 NCI cancer centers. Are there practices that are routine at NCI centers which could be "implemented" at non-NCI centers to improve outcomes?

Best,

Tim

In reply to Timothy

Re: Assignment 1

by Ekland Abdiwahab -

Thanks for the feedback, Timothy. Still thinking through practical interventions. Will look into differences between Non-NCICCCs and NCICCCs which is briefly touched upon in the Wolfson article. 


In reply to Ekland Abdiwahab

Re: Assignment 1

by David Hoskins -

Hi Ekland, interesting and much needed research. Similar to Timothy, I am wondering whether the intervention should address linkage to care or bigger policy shifts. Given our current political climate, the latter seems a bit difficult at the moment. Look forward to reading more.